Insights at Pro Management ·

The most expensive resignation is the one nobody ever voices.

How managers can spot when employees are pulling away and what they can do about it.

By Pro Management

Some employees resign and leave the company. Others stay even though, in their minds, they checked out long ago.

The second is often much harder for managers to spot.

The employee still arrives on time, does their work and keeps a low profile. Everything seems fine. Only when you look more closely do you see that something has changed.

They used to bring ideas, suggest improvements and sometimes challenge a decision. Today they do what's required. Nothing more, nothing less.

In conversations with managers, I often find that these changes go unnoticed for a long time. It's not necessarily that managers don't care. Day-to-day work is busy, the numbers look good and other matters seem more urgent.

This is precisely where it pays to look closer.

People rarely check out of their jobs overnight

Often there isn't one big event that makes someone withdraw.

It's a series of little things.

A decision nobody explained. An achievement that went unrecognised. A development conversation that kept getting postponed. Or a feeling that their opinion makes no difference anyway.

Of course, managers aren't responsible for every source of dissatisfaction. People have different expectations, personal challenges and hopes for their careers.

Even so, every manager should regularly ask themselves whether they really know how their team is doing.

And I don't mean the obligatory “Everything all right?” in the corridor.

When did you last really listen?

Many companies hold regular conversations with employees. That's a good and worthwhile practice.

But an appointment in the calendar doesn't make for a good conversation.

Sometimes an hour goes by discussing goals, metrics and tasks, and the manager still doesn't learn what's really on the employee's mind.

Even simple questions can make a big difference.

What are you enjoying most right now? What frustrates you in your day-to-day work? Is there anything we should change? What would you like from me as your manager?

The real challenge is listening to the answer, even when it's uncomfortable.

If you ask employees for their opinion, you have to be prepared to hear more than praise.

That's part of it.

Appreciation means more than a friendly thank-you

One thing often underestimated in everyday working relationships is recognition.

That doesn't mean managers should be praising employees all the time.

But good work should be noticed. Someone who takes responsibility, puts in the effort or finds a sound solution in a difficult situation wants to feel that it was seen.

Clear expectations matter just as much.

People can only do their work well when they know what's expected of them, which decisions they can make themselves and how their performance will be assessed.

Without that direction, frustration can build quickly.

Leadership doesn't happen only at the annual review

Good management shows up most clearly in everyday work.

In how decisions are explained. In how mistakes are handled. In whether promises are kept and how managers respond when things get difficult.

That doesn't require a steady supply of new leadership models.

It takes attention, reliability and a willingness to engage with people.

That sounds obvious. In practice, it often isn't.

Leading a team means being accountable for results. It also means taking responsibility for how people work together.

The two go together.

What does this mean for companies?

Companies spend a lot of money attracting new employees. Job advertisements, recruiters, selection and onboarding all cost time and resources.

That makes it all the more surprising how little attention sometimes goes to the people already working there.

Employee retention can't simply be handed off to HR.

It's built every day in the way managers and teams work together.

If you wait until an employee hands in their notice to start the conversation, you're often too late.

And assuming an employee is motivated simply because they come to work every morning is taking too much for granted.

Sometimes the most expensive resignation really is the one nobody ever voices.

Jochen Kracht, member of the Executive Board of Pro Management AG

Would you like to develop your skills in this area?

Discover the right training course or discuss an in-house request with us.